I remember when this no block question in karate began in the mid 1980's. As
I recall it came about when people started being exposed to the Okinawan kata
bunkai and finding out that not all blocks were for just blocking. It is my
belief that this line of thinking got completely out of control as people
started trying to understand each  movement of the kata and making it some
exotic explanation to further their position in the world of how much they
knew about the kata. Many of these people following this line of thinking
were those that stated that the Okinawans were hiding all the deadly
techniques from westerners and even the Japanese. Some even went as far as
saying that the Okinawan senior teachers got together after World War Two and
decided not to teach the deadly art of Uchinandi again.

Are there blocks in Okinawan karate kata ? Certainly and the number of
blocking techniques that are used for protecting you against attack are far
greater than those that are used for release from a grab.

The basic teaching of all Okinawa kata is the same regardless of style. The
following three principles are taught in the same order by each teacher and
is developed through the understanding of the kata. The words that I use to
describe these three principles may not be the same but the actions are.

1. Get out of the way - tai sabaki. This is accomplished in varying ways
depending on the teacher but it is all the same. If someone attacks you the
first thing you want to do is get out of the way. (This helps disrupt the
kuzushi of the opponent)
2. Protect your vital areas as you move out of the way of the attack. You do
this with blocking. You may not actually block (whatever that is) the attack
but you certainly want to protect your vital areas while you are getting out
of the way. Addtionally by making contact with the opponents attack with a
block (no matter what type of block it is) you give the opponent the feedback
that they are looking for. They have made contact. (This helps disrupt the
kuzushi of the opponent)
3. Attack the opponents vital areas that have been exposed by their attack,
your evasion and blocking. The Okinawan concept is to do this as one movement
if possible (ikkyo). If you use these three principles in concert you should
accomplish ikken haistsu.

The Okinawans spend many hours developing the blocking movements so that they
can apply them as I have outlined above. It is just as important to learn how
to move and block as it does to attack and is more vital to your safety.

 What happens when the scenario above does not work is where in the kata the
techniques of escaping a grasp or your own counter attack being blocked is
where the confusion can come from understanding whether a technique was a
block as described above or not.

In my opinion I have answered several questions posed on the CD over the last
few days.  What is kuzushi ? How is Kuzushi applied from the kata ? Are their
blocks in Okinawan kata ? Is there just bunkai from Okinawa that has only
block/punch applications ? Is there use of blocking and striking simultaneous
in Okinawa karate ?

IMHO all of these questions are answered in the three principles. Of course
there is much more to be found in the section of what techniques are used
when these three principles cannot be applied. I believe that most people
want to find this answer before understanding the first three principles.
Once you can apply the above principles it makes understanding the ti
techniques that are woven into the kata.

I hope that this was helpful to those that are asking the questions and I
hope it will interject thinking about the kata from a different perspective.
Everything starts with the footwork.

Gumbatte

Dan Smith

Go to letter 4